Series: Understanding MSDS | Post 7 of 52
Standard 1 (ROM-1) | Indicator 4 | Category: YELLOW (80% required)
Four Lines on a Small Plate
Dr. Tariq Javed had been practicing medicine in Sialkot for fourteen years.
He was, by any reasonable measure, a careful man. His prescriptions were legible. His patient files were organized in a colour-coded system that his receptionist had once described, with some pride, as “better than most hospitals.” He had attended four CME workshops in the past two years. When the PHC assessment notice arrived, he read it the same day and started preparing the following morning.
He spent that week working through his clinic systematically, front to back, outer wall to inner rooms. Signboard: compliant, PM&DC number added. Access: ground floor, no steps, door width checked. PHC license: framed and displayed at the entrance. He was methodical. He was confident.
The assessor arrived on a Thursday at eleven in the morning. She was pleasant and professional, and she began, as assessors do, at the outside of the clinic and worked her way in. She reviewed the signboard. She checked the entrance. She examined the PHC license copy in the waiting area.
Then she reached the door.
On it was a small brass plate. Elegant, actually, the kind a person notices and thinks looks professional. It read:
DR. TARIQ JAVED
MBBS, FCPS (Surgery), MRCS (Edinburgh), FACS
Ex-Associate Professor, Allama Iqbal Medical College
Surgical Specialist | Morning: 10am to 2pm | Evening: 6pm to 9pm
Four lines. One qualification that raised a question. One past appointment that crossed a specific line.
The assessor looked at the plate for a moment. Then she asked Dr. Tariq: “Is the FACS registered with the PM&DC?”
He said he believed it was. She made a note and asked him to provide evidence. He opened his files, found his PM&DC registration certificate, and read it carefully, something he had not done in several years.
The MRCS (Edinburgh) was listed. The FACS was not.
One line on a plate had been there for eleven years without anyone questioning it. It took the MSDS assessment to surface it.
“And the ‘Ex-Associate Professor’ line,” the assessor said, returning to the door, “under the guidelines, past appointments are not to appear here.”
Dr. Tariq looked at his door plate, the one that had seemed like nothing, just a small identifying sign he had put up when he opened this clinic, and understood that it contained at least two non-conformities the MSDS considered significant.
What Indicator 4 Actually Requires
Indicator 4 sits under Standard 1 of the Responsibilities of Management section, alongside the signboard, easy access, PHC registration and consultation hours. Like the indicators before it, it belongs to the overarching requirement that the clinic must be identifiable as a legal entity. But this indicator operates at a more personal level: not the large board outside, but the small plate on the door.
The indicator reads: Door plate clearly displays name and qualification/s of the doctor.
The survey process asks the assessor to observe the placement of the door plate and whether its text follows the PM&DC Code of Ethics of Practice for Medical and Dental Practitioners.
The requirements have two parts: the physical standard and the content standard.
The Physical Standard
The door plate should be placed on the door of the clinic. The manual asks for a modest plate, with a recommended size not exceeding 4 inches by 10 inches, and wording of an appropriate size and font in a maximum of three lines.
The sample plate in the manual carries just two things: the doctor’s name and the qualifications. That is the heart of the plate: who you are and what you are qualified in.
The manual adds one more point that surprises some doctors. The doctor’s name should not be used on any other clinic or premises except the place of regular practice, where the practice timings are also displayed.
The Content Standard, and the Caution
This is where Indicator 4 has a formal edge that many clinic owners do not encounter until it is too late.
The manual states that the plate must include qualifications, invariably indicating the granting authority, and that these must be degrees, diplomas or specializations recognized or registered by the PM&DC. It then adds an explicit Caution:
“Only the qualification/s registered by the PM&DC in recognized abbreviation/s is/are permitted to be displayed.”
“Past/present appointments and membership with associations or bodies shall not be mentioned on the board/s.”
In practice, this means two things.
First: only PM&DC-registered qualifications may appear. A doctor may have attended international training programmes, earned overseas diplomas, passed foreign college examinations or received certifications from professional associations. Some of these are PM&DC-registered. Many are not. If a qualification is not on your PM&DC certificate, it is not permitted on your door plate, regardless of how legitimate or hard-earned it is.
Second: past and present appointments and memberships are entirely excluded. No “Ex-CMO”, no “Consultant to XYZ Hospital”, no “Fellow, Pakistan Surgical Society”, no “Member, Pakistan Medical Association”, no “Ex-Associate Professor”. These are professional achievements that may be accurate and may be a source of genuine pride. They belong on a curriculum vitae, not on a door plate.
The reasoning is the same as for the signboard. A patient standing at your door should be able to read your plate and trust that everything on it represents a verified, PM&DC-registered credential. Titles and affiliations cannot be independently verified by a patient, and some are used by practitioners of questionable standing to create a misleading impression. The MSDS clears them off completely rather than trying to distinguish legitimate from misleading case by case.
How the Assessor Scores This Indicator
This is a YELLOW indicator, and the manual gives three possible outcomes.
Fully met: the door plate is in accordance with the requirements above, showing the doctor’s name and PM&DC-registered qualifications, with no non-permitted content.
Partially met: the door plate is present but does not display the requisite information as required. A qualification that is not PM&DC-registered, a past appointment or a membership on the plate places it here.
Not met: there is no door plate.
Dr. Tariq’s plate was scored as partially met. The plate existed, and his name, MBBS, FCPS and MRCS were correct. But the FACS was not registered with the PM&DC, and the past appointment line was a clear non-conformity.
A Detail That Saves Time: Check Your PM&DC Certificate First
Before your assessment, the single most useful action you can take for Indicator 4 is to pull your current PM&DC registration certificate and read the qualifications listed on it.
Every qualification on your door plate must be traceable to that certificate. If your plate carries qualifications that are not on your PM&DC certificate, such as foreign memberships or international diplomas, you need to either confirm that they are PM&DC-registered or remove them from the plate.
The assessor may ask you to demonstrate, on the spot, that a qualification on your door plate is PM&DC-registered. “I think it is” is not a sufficient answer. The evidence must be available.
What Dr. Tariq Did
The evening after the assessment, Dr. Tariq ordered a new door plate.
He removed the FACS, because it was not on his PM&DC certificate. He removed the “Ex-Associate Professor” line entirely, as the guidelines required. He kept the MRCS, having confirmed it was PM&DC-registered, and wrote it with its granting authority. He trimmed the plate to three clean lines and a size within the 4 by 10 inch limit.
The new plate read:
DR. TARIQ JAVED
MBBS, FCPS (Surgery), MRCS (Edin)
10am to 2pm | 6pm to 9pm
Smaller. Shorter. Compliant.
He had the plate made at a local signboard shop in two days for under fifteen hundred rupees. At his reassessment, Indicator 4 was fully met.
“The strange thing,” he said later to a colleague preparing for his own assessment, “is that I never thought of the door plate as a regulated item. I thought it was just identification. But everything facing the patient, from the board on the street to the plate on the door, is regulated. The patient sees it before they see you.”
A Quick Self-Check Before You Move On
Go to your clinic door right now and read the plate as if you are a stranger seeing it for the first time.
- Is there a plate on the door? If not, this needs to be added.
- Does the plate clearly show your name and your PM&DC-registered qualifications?
- Does the plate show any qualification that is not listed on your PM&DC registration certificate? If so, verify its PM&DC status or remove it.
- Does the plate mention any past appointment, current affiliation or association membership? If so, remove it. The Caution in the MSDS is unambiguous on this point.
- Does the plate exceed 4 by 10 inches or run to more than three lines? If so, a replacement within the limits is straightforward and inexpensive.
Indicator 4 is a YELLOW indicator. Most clinics that engage with it seriously, and replace what needs replacing, meet it without difficulty. The ones that struggle are those that do not look at the plate at all.
Rate this article
How useful was it for you?
UPMED reads every review; some are shown on this page.
Log in to write a few lines too.